RDR2 Legendary Fish: All Locations and the Right Lure (2026)
- ๐ฏ 13, 14 or 15 RDR2 Legendary Fish? Why the Counts Differ
- ๐บ๏ธ All RDR2 Legendary Fish: Locations and Lures
- ๐งช The Lure Logic: Learn It Once, Never Look It Up Again
- ๐ฆ Requirements: When You Can Start
- โจ Rewards for 1, 10 and 13 Fish
- โ ๏ธ The Two Special Cases: Channel Catfish and Legendary Northern Pike
- ๐ What to Do with Your Fish Afterward
- ๐ก Four Tricks to Speed Up the Catch
- โ FAQ about RDR2 Legendary Fish
To finish the Stranger mission "A Fisher of Fish", you have to send 13 RDR2 legendary fish to Jeremy Gill. The 14th, the Channel Catfish, only comes afterward on the fishing trip with Gill and can't be caught freely. Which lure you need depends only on the type of water: Special River, Lake or Swamp Lure, $20 each at the bait shop.
The complete table with fish, location and lure is right below.
๐ฏ 13, 14 or 15 RDR2 Legendary Fish? Why the Counts Differ
This is where most guides contradict each other, and the answer is simple: there are three different numbers that mean three different things.
- 13 is the number that counts for the mission. You mail only these 13 fish to Jeremy Gill.
- 14 is the number of fish you get across the whole fishing questline. The 14th is the Channel Catfish. It's the reward, not the task.
- 15 is what GTABase counts, because it also includes the Legendary Northern Pike. That one has nothing to do with Jeremy Gill and is tied to Hamish Sinclair's Stranger mission "The Veteran II".
So if one site tells you 13 and the next says 15, both are right. They just count differently. For the mission checkmark you need 13.
๐บ๏ธ All RDR2 Legendary Fish: Locations and Lures
| Fish | Region and location | Special lure |
|---|---|---|
| Legendary Steelhead Trout | Roanoke Ridge, Kamassa River northeast of Brandywine Drop | River |
| Legendary Perch | New Hanover, Elysian Pool southwest of Annesburg | Lake |
| Legendary Longnose Gar | Bluewater Marsh, south shore at Lakay near Lagras | Swamp |
| Legendary Muskie | Lannahechee River, south of Van Horn Trading Post by the lighthouse | River |
| Legendary Bullhead Catfish | island west of Sisika Penitentiary, east of Saint Denis | River |
| Legendary Lake Sturgeon | south of Saint Denis, at the railroad bridge near Caliga Hall | River |
| Legendary Bluegill | Flat Iron Lake, between Rhodes and Braithwaite Manor | Lake |
| Legendary Chain Pickerel | Dakota River, S-bend east of Flatneck Station | River |
| Legendary Sockeye Salmon | Ambarino, south shore of Lake Isabella | Lake |
| Legendary Smallmouth Bass | Owanjila, east shore near Strawberry | Lake |
| Legendary Rock Bass | Aurora Basin, west of Blackwater in Tall Trees | Lake |
| Legendary Redfin Pickerel | Stillwater Creek, western stretch near MacFarlane's Ranch | Lake |
| Legendary Largemouth Bass | New Austin, San Luis River near Lake Don Julio | River (see note) |
| Legendary Channel Catfish | San Luis River south of Benedict Point, only on the fishing trip with Gill | not needed, Gill provides the bait |
An honest note on the Largemouth Bass: RDR2.org and GameRevolution both list the River Lure, while the German GameStar guide lists the Lake Lure. The San Luis River is a river, so the River Lure is listed here. Bring both anyway in case the first attempt doesn't work. For the Channel Catfish the question is moot, because the fishing trip provides the gear.
๐งช The Lure Logic: Learn It Once, Never Look It Up Again
The real trick with RDR2 legendary fish isn't a list, it's a rule. Regular bait like bread, corn, cheese or worms doesn't work on legendary fish. You need one of the three special lures, and you pick it by the water you're standing at:
- Special River Lure: flowing water, like the Kamassa, Dakota, Lannahechee and San Luis River.
- Special Lake Lure: still water, like Flat Iron Lake, Lake Isabella, Owanjila, Aurora Basin and Elysian Pool.
- Special Swamp Lure: the bayou around Lagras and Lakay. In practice it only matters for one fish, the Longnose Gar.
Each one costs $20 and is available at the bait shop in Lagras once you've met Jeremy Gill. They can be reused without limit, so you buy each exactly once. Count on $60 in total for all three. That's the complete material cost for the whole mission.
In practice, you don't have to memorize 13 assignments. You look at the water in front of you and know the lure. The table above is just the shortcut.
๐ฆ Requirements: When You Can Start
The Stranger mission "A Fisher of Fish" starts from Chapter 3 with Jeremy Gill at the northeast corner of Flat Iron Lake, near Gill Landing. He gives you the map with all locations and unlocks the special lures for purchase. Before that, you can't catch the fish, even if you're standing in the right spot.
After that it all runs through the mail: take every fish you catch to the nearest post office and send it off. Medium fish fit in your satchel, large ones go on your horse. According to the community wiki reddead.fandom.com, your horse carries only one large fish at a time, and it decomposes there over time like an animal carcass unless you own the Pronghorn Horn Trinket. So get large fish to the post office quickly.
โจ Rewards for 1, 10 and 13 Fish
| Milestone | Reward |
|---|---|
| 1st fish sent | Special Lake Lure |
| 10th fish sent | 5 fish fillets and $45 |
| 13th fish sent | a special lure plus an invitation to the fishing trip with Gill |
The invitation arrives as a letter at the post office a few in-game days later. Only this trip gets you the Channel Catfish. So the 14th fish isn't something you can accidentally miss. It's simply the end of the chain.
โ ๏ธ The Two Special Cases: Channel Catfish and Legendary Northern Pike
Neither fish can be ticked off on the normal route, and both are gone for good once caught.
- Legendary Channel Catfish: only on the fishing trip with Jeremy Gill in the San Luis River south of Benedict Point. According to RDR2.org, it's more active in overcast weather.
- Legendary Northern Pike: only during "The Veteran II" with Hamish Sinclair at O'Creagh's Run in Grizzlies East, Ambarino. GTABase explicitly notes that it doesn't respawn after you catch it and isn't needed for the "Zoologist" and "Skin Deep" achievements. If you search for the Legendary Northern Pike location and can't find it in a fishing guide, that's why.
๐ What to Do with Your Fish Afterward
The legendary fish themselves go in the mail, but the 5 fish fillets from the 10-fish reward and everything else you catch while practicing belong in the pan. In camp, fish is the cheapest way to restore Stamina. How to make the best meal out of it is in the RDR2 flaky fish guide.
If you move from Story Mode to multiplayer, you'll find the cooking mechanic in a similar form there, with different values: see the Red Dead Online cooking guide. Note that legendary fish don't exist in Red Dead Online at all. If you've only just started and want to try multiplayer afterward, the Red Dead Online beginners guide is the right next step.
One nice side effect: RDR2's Story Mode hasn't had content updates in years, and the fishing mechanic has been unchanged since release. Locations, lure assignments and rewards in this guide therefore still apply, unlike in games that shift something with every patch.
๐ก Four Tricks to Speed Up the Catch
- Watch the weather: for several legendary fish, overcast, gray weather is the better time according to RDR2.org and GTABase. Sleeping until the weather changes saves attempts.
- Route over order: the mission has no set order. Collect by geography: first everything around Saint Denis and Lagras, then New Hanover, then the west.
- One large fish per trip: since your horse carries only one large fish at a time and it decomposes there, plan your way back to the post office right away.
- Shorten the fight: once the fish is tired, pulling the left stick down raises the rod and noticeably shortens the reeling phase.
โ FAQ about RDR2 Legendary Fish
How many legendary fish are there in RDR2?
13 count for "A Fisher of Fish". With the Channel Catfish from the fishing trip it's 14, and with the Legendary Northern Pike from "The Veteran II" it's 15. All three numbers go around because they count different things.
Which lure for legendary fish?
Always a special lure, never regular bait. Which one depends on the water: river, lake or swamp. Each costs $20 and can be reused without limit.
Where do I get the special lures?
At the bait shop in Lagras in Bayou Nwa, after you've met Jeremy Gill at Flat Iron Lake. Before that, they aren't in stock.
Can I keep the legendary fish?
No. For mission progress you have to mail them to Jeremy Gill. Keeping them gives you no advantage, since they can't be used for anything else.
Where is the Legendary Northern Pike?
At O'Creagh's Run in Ambarino, but only during Hamish Sinclair's Stranger mission "The Veteran II". Outside that mission you can't catch it, and it doesn't come back after you've caught it.
From which chapter can I start?
From Chapter 3. Before that you don't meet Jeremy Gill and can't get the map or the special lures.
Checked as of October 2026. All details in this guide were checked against the location and lure tables of RDR2.org and GameRevolution, GTABase's animal database and reddead.fandom.com, and they agree on every point except the marked Largemouth Bass lure.